How to Obtain
Thanksgiving Event 2023 — trade only
About the Pumpkin Pie
The Pumpkin Pie is an Uncommon knife in Roblox Murder Mystery 2 that became available during the 2023 Thanksgiving Event. Players could obtain it by collecting 2,800 coins and claiming it from the tier system. As of 2026, this festive knife is only obtainable through trading, making it a seasonal collector's item in MM2.
Trading Tips
With relatively low demand, Pumpkin Pie tends to hold value around T1 Legendary. Trade it individually for other uncommon items or combine it with adds for rare-tier trades.
Related Items
Uncommon
Pumpkin Patch (2025)
Knife
Available
Godly
Pumpking
Knife
Unavailable
Godly
Turkey
Knife
Unavailable
Want the Pumpkin Pie?
Earn Icey points for free by completing surveys & offers - then redeem them for real Roblox items.
Start Earning Free →